Both new ways:
1 Google screen.
0 stray accounts.
Today, a fresh phone abroad can guess the wrong home. Then you see Google twice.
is wrong
on our screen
broker service
Today shows Google twice. A and B show it once.
Same person, same trip abroad. Read each row left to right.
Today guesses. A and B look it up.
Press play, or step with the arrow keys. Watch the moving dot.
Measured 5 times each. Same result every run.
All runs used a fresh browser and a wrong first guess.
Google screens seen
per sign-in
The red box is the second Google screen.
Stray accounts left behind
in 5 test runs
Each circle is one run. A ghost means a stray account was made.
Time to sign in
seconds, middle of 5 runs
Machine time on one test computer. Real networks add a little. Not yet timed on a real network.
A stolen copy: how long does it work?
Way A's copy works for a full hour. Way B's dies in about 2 minutes.
The other side: a new master key
One key that can sign in anyone.
Our sign-in servers trust Google directly.
If it leaks, someone can sign in as anyone. It needs a locked key vault.
5 serious gaps. Fixes known. None built yet.
A security check found them. A second check proved each one on a test copy.
A stranger's Google sign-in can be finished in your browser.
Tie each sign-in to the browser that started it.
The 2-minute note can be copied and reused, many times.
Make the note work only once.
Our other sign-in sites can read the note, or plant a fake one.
Lock the note to the broker's own address.
If the home list is down, people get a new account in the wrong region.
Stop with an error. Never guess.
A leaked broker key signs in anyone, even password users.
Key in a locked vault. No automatic account joining by email.
Must-fixes built so far. The 5 above, plus 5 smaller ones like rate limits and an audit log.
Way A's open issues
Not ours to fix. It is how the sign-in server takes Google's token.
Only possible if we change the sign-in server's own code.
Pick way B. Build the fixes in first.
B does more, and guards more paths. Its gaps are known and fixable.
| Question | Way A | Way B |
|---|---|---|
| 1 Google screen abroad | yes | yes |
| 0 stray accounts | yes | yes |
| Apple sign-in | no | yes |
| Starts on a sign-in page | needs a guard | sends you home |
| A stolen copy works for | 1 hour | about 2 min |
| New master key | none | one, in 2 regions |
| New service to run | none | a small one per region |
| One region goes down | nothing new to fail | other region finishes |
Way B, with the 10 must-fixes built in.
Do the fixes before it goes live.
- One way in for both Google and Apple.
- Guards every path, even a stale home.
- Way A stays a fallback for Google only.